Skip to main content

Microsoft sues Motorola…again

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Microsoft has filed a new lawsuit against Motorola, claiming the technology giant is charging Microsoft “excessive and discriminatory” fees to license technology Microsoft uses to implement both 802.11 Wi-Fi networking and H.264 video compression technology. Microsoft says the fees violate Motorola’s legal commitments to organizations that manage these technology standards.

The suit alleges that Motorola is seeking license fees based on the retail prices of Microsoft products using the technologies—that would include Windows 7, Windows Phone 7, and Xbox 360 game consoles—rather than license fees based on the prices of the individual component hardware and software related to implementing the specific features related to Motorola technology. Microsoft argues that both Wi-Fi and H.264 video encoding are secondary features of its products, rather than primary features, and therefore Motorola’s licensing fee demands are unreasonable.

Recommended Videos

Microsoft also notes that as a member of both the International Telecommunications Union (ITU) and the IEEE, Motorola is obligated to provide “reasonable and non-discriminatory” licensing for its patents that are included in the Wi-Fi and H.264 standards. Microsoft is asking the court to force Motorola to offer licenses on what Microsoft considers reasonable terms, as well as award it damages to make up for losses incurred from what it sees as overcharging.

Motorola has not commented on the suit, saying only that the companies have not been able to reach an agreement on licensing terms.

The suit was filed in a federal court in Seattle, and is the second Microsoft has filed against Motorola in recent weeks. Last month, Microsoft sued Motorola, claiming its Android smartphones infringe on nine Microsoft patents.

Geoff Duncan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
Upcoming Soulslike delayed indefinitely on Xbox due to ‘challenges’ with Microsoft
A character in Enotria: The Last Song. It's wearing a burnt masquerade mask, with green and red fabric attached.

Enotria: The Last Song, an upcoming Soulslike inspired by Italian mythology, was set to release on Xbox Series X/S alongside PlayStation 5 and PC on September 19. However, the developers announced on Monday that the Xbox version is being delayed indefinitely.

According to a statement on the game's website, a spokesperson from Jyamma Games wrote that the team "encountered challenges" when getting the version ready for launch. The post was more vague on the kinds of issues the team faced: "We understand how disappointing this news is to the Xbox community. Unfortunately, despite our best efforts and the hard work of our dedicated team, we’ve encountered challenges that have delayed our release on the Xbox platform. We want to emphasize that this is not a decision we’ve made lightly," the post reads.

Read more
The best Xbox 360 games of all time
xbox one backwards compatible december 2015 halo reach 360 compatability waypoint featured

The Xbox 360 is a console that defined an entire generation of gamers and inspired some of the best Xbox One games to follow. There was still competition with the best PS3 games and the best Wii games, but the 360 managed to hold its own against those two titans.

Many of the best games of all time appeared on this beloved console, which made narrowing down this list of the best Xbox 360 games a real challenge. Whether you're playing on original hardware or taking a break from the best Xbox Series X games and using backward compatibility, these are the best games you can play on the Xbox 360.

Read more
This is your last chance to get some heavily discounted Xbox 360 games
A chopper-esque contraption flying towards a giant monster in a city. The player character is shooting a gun at it.

Microsoft announced last year that it would be shutting down the Xbox 360 Marketplace at the end of July, but it's not over just yet. Xbox is running a massive fire sale on a number of games, with some going as low as $1.

Players won't be able to purchase any products through the storefront after it goes offline on July 29. While you can still download and play games you already own, you won't be able to watch movies or TV since the Movies & TV app will also stop working on that date. That means now is your last chance to fill up your library.

Read more