Skip to main content

This underrated mystery series is climbing the Netflix charts. Is it worth watching?

Zahn McClarnon and Kiowa Gordon in Dark Winds.
AMC

The AMC+ invasion of Netflix has begun, and to no one’s surprise, these series are now holding four out of the 10 slots on the list of the most popular shows on Netflix. But you might be shocked to hear that Dark Winds has risen to the No. 3 slot above all of the other AMC shows, including Fear the Walking Dead.

Dark Winds may not get the big ratings like AMC’s endless Walking Dead spinoffs, but it’s a fantastic show and fans are already starting to flock to it now that it has a much wider reach than AMC+ could have ever given it. However, if you need to be convinced to check out this buzzy series, then here are four reasons to watch Dark Winds on Netflix.

Recommended Videos

The show gives Zahn McClarnon the spotlight he deserves

Zahn McClarnon in Dark Winds.
AMC

Westworld fans can attest that Zahn McClarnon is a gifted performer who can be mesmerizing without uttering a single word of English. He did just that in a standout episode of Westworld season 2, as his character, Akecheta, unravels his personal narrative in the Lakota language. McClarnon has had plenty of supporting turns prior to and after Westworld, but Dark Winds was his first real chance to step up and headline a drama series.

In this show, McClarnon gets to use all of the tools in his acting arsenal as Joe Leaphorn, a lieutenant for the tribal police of Navajo County during the 1970s. He is undeniably the star of the series, and McClarnon does a magnificent job of making his character seem like a real person. Even McClarnon’s tiniest gestures, facial expressions, and movements convey Leaphorn’s thoughts and emotions. He gets to be the complicated hero that Dark Winds needs, and he’s a fantastic leading man in the series.

Dark Winds utilizes Native American writers and actors

Kiowa Gordon and Jessica Matten in Dark Winds
AMC

Tony Hillerman, the author of the Leaphorn & Chee novels that the show is based on, was not a Native American. Hillerman told excellent stories with indigenous characters, but Dark Winds showrunner Graham Roland went several steps further by recruiting a team of exclusively Native American screenwriters to script the show. The writers and producers have also demonstrated a commitment to portraying Navajo culture as accurately as possible.

That commitment extends in front of the camera as well, as Kiowa Gordon and Jessica Matten co-star in the series as Jim Chee and Bernadette Manuelito, respectively. Their relationships with McClarnon’s Leaphorn are the backbone of the series, and they’re far from the only Native American actors on the show. Dark Winds is one of the few TV series to ever offer these kinds of opportunities to native performers, and it stands out because of that.

The mysteries keep us guessing

Zahn McClarnon in Dark Winds.
AMC

Dark Winds wouldn’t be as interesting as it is if Leaphorn and Chee didn’t have to solve some mysteries along the way. The show is set in the 1970s, so modern forensic science hasn’t quite arrived yet and the pair have to do some old-fashioned legwork to investigate the dueling cases of the first season. Leaphorn is more concerned about getting to the bottom of a double homicide in his territory, while Chee is looking for some armored truck robbers who are hiding out in Navajo County.

It’s not a big spoiler to say that the two cases are intimately connected. But since the vast majority of viewers aren’t likely to have read the novels that inspired the show, the twists are more than enough to keep audiences on their toes.

Dark Winds’ 12 episodes are easy to binge

Zahn McClarnon in Dark Winds.
AMC

As a personal preference, I like shows that have lots of episodes to watch. However, the short six-episode seasons for Dark Winds works in the series’ favor because it’s like a great book you can’t put down. With only 12 episodes across the two seasons to date, most veteran binge-watchers can blow through the entire run in less than a week. Or even a day, if you’re a hardcore binge-watcher.

Almost all of the answers you want from the show are waiting for you, so you never have to be in suspense for too long. That’s one of the benefits of the streaming era. And if Dark Winds turns out to be one of your new favorites, then we’ve got good news for you. A third season is on the way, but you’ll probably have to watch that on AMC. Like the other recent arrivals from AMC+, Dark Winds won’t be a permanent fixture on Netflix. So enjoy it while you can.

Watch Dark Winds on Netflix.

Blair Marnell
Blair Marnell has been an entertainment journalist for over 15 years. His bylines have appeared in Wizard Magazine, Geek…
If you have to watch one Netflix show in February 2025, stream this one
The cast of A Different World.

During 2024, Netflix added many classic sitcoms from the 1990s, including Martin, The Jamie Foxx Show, and Reba. That's given those shows a chance to find a new audience in the streaming era. This month, the streamer is doing it again with A Different World, and it's our pick for the one Netflix show that you have to watch in February.

This is significant because A Different World hasn't been readily available to stream or purchase on digital outlets. It's also been unjustly dragged down by the controversy surrounding Bill Cosby and the sexual assault allegations against him that has relegated The Cosby Show to streaming purgatory. A Different World is a spinoff from The Cosby Show, and characters from the latter did show up in the former. However, A Different World also established its own identity as a comedy, especially once Lisa Bonet, the original lead of the series, left the show.

Read more
3 underrated Netflix shows you should watch this weekend (January 24-26)
The cast of HBO's Insecure

Netflix wants to be your television home, and it's been remarkably successful in that endeavor. The streamer features an amazing lineup of excellent shows, but when it's time to find something to watch, you might be at a bit of a loss over what to pick.
Thankfully, that's where we come in. We've pulled together a lineup of underrated series that are available on the streaming service, whether you're looking for something that will be over relatively quickly or a much longer commitment. These are three underrated shows on Netflix you should make time for this weekend.

We also have guides to the best movies on Netflix, the best movies on Hulu, the best movies on Amazon Prime Video, the best movies on Max, and the best movies on Disney+.
Insecure (2016-2021)
Insecure - Trailer - Official HBO UK
The show that justifiably became Issa Rae's calling card, Insecure chronicles a very specific slice of modern black female life. Crucially, the show is always rooted in the perspectives of its two deeply flawed central characters, Issa and Molly, both of whom deal with a variety of major and minor crises over the course of several years in their lives.
Insecure is funny, real, and remarkably open-hearted even about its more objectionable characters. Featuring an outstanding array of Black talent, the series deserved every bit of acclaim it received and its extended run on HBO.
You can watch Insecure on Netflix.
Unorthodox (2020)
UNORTHODOX Trailer (2020) Netflix
A brilliant, sensitive look at Hasidic Judaism in the United States, Unorthodox tells the story of a woman who flees from an arranged marriage in Brooklyn in order to find a new life. When the past starts to catch up, she faces hard choices about what her future should be.
Unorthodox features a stunning central performance from Shira Haas, and it's one of the best Netflix miniseries to fly entirely under the radar. It might not be focused on true crime, but Unorthodox will leave you on the edge of your seat.
You can watch Unorthodox on Netflix.
The Pacific (2010)
'Our Cause Is Just' Trailer | The Pacific | HBO Classics
A spiritual sequel to Band of Brothers, The Pacific focuses on troops stationed on the other major front of the war. This series was every bit as gripping and acclaimed as its predecessor, but it hasn't had the same staying power. Based on true accounts of Pacific soldiers, the series chronicles their journey from Guadalcanal to Iwo Jima, Okinawa, and ultimately to their return home in the aftermath of V-J Day.
Produced by Tom Hanks and Steven Spielberg, the series is a brilliant reflection of the joys and immense sorrow of being a soldier in one of the bloodiest conflicts in human history.
You can watch The Pacific on Netflix.

Read more
Netflix CEO opens up about the David Lynch TV series that was almost made
David Lynch wears an FBI badge in Twin Peaks: The Return.

The world was rocked this week when visionary filmmaker David Lynch passed away at the age of 78. Many of Lynch's admirers, as well as plenty of his former collaborators, have since gone out of their way to publicly mourn his passing and pay tribute to his work. The growing list of those who have taken the time to honor Lynch now includes Netflix co-CEO Ted Sarandos, who took to Instagram to celebrate one of his "all time favorite filmmakers."

Sarandos specifically recalled the time when Lynch came close to making "his last project" with Netflix. "He came into Netflix to pitch a limited series which we jumped at. It was a David Lynch production, so filled with mystery and risks but we wanted to go on this creative ride with this genius," the Netflix executive explained. "First COVID, then some health uncertainties [led] to this project never being produced but we made it clear that as soon as he was able, we were all in."

Read more